Will Ludwigsens Acres of Perhaps Rotating Header Image

ExerTrek: Face of the Enemy

[One man. One exercise bike. One surgery. 140/178 episodes of Star Trek: The Next Generation.]

The original title for this episode was better: “The Hunt for Green October.”

Troi is kidnapped and surgically altered to help Romulan defectors cross the Neutral Zone, and she must pretend to be a terrifying agent for the Romulan intelligence service to save herself and the defectors.

Aside from a few tense moments in which Troi barely holds onto her cover story and a somewhat clever means of getting the defectors aboard the Enterprise, there isn’t much to recommend this episode. It feels mailed in, though Marina Sirtis certainly earns her paycheck while everyone else goofs off.

There’s a weird tipping point here in this season when it seems clear that everyone is just tired and ready for this Star Trek shit to finally end. A few exceptions represent surges of creative energy, but I think it’s a little too apparent that this is all someone’s job by now.

Or maybe I’m just projecting.

My grade: D

[Time on bike: 25 minutes.]

ExerTrek: Aquiel

[One man. One exercise bike. One surgery. 139/178 episodes of Star Trek: The Next Generation.]

I love a good mystery full of red herrings, cross purposes, and shadowed motivations. I love investigations, too: gathering evidence into a coherent representation of the truth, however flawed.

So I should like this episode. But I don’t.

Here, the Enterprise comes upon a communications relay station with its crew missing and a suspicious stain of organic matter fused to a deck plate. Geordi views the logs of a female crew member and comes to like her, which works out well when they find her alive at the beginning of the second act. Various accusations and investigations ensue, and the perp turns out to be a malevolent Shmoo-like creature that absorbs other organisms and takes on their characteristics.

Huh. Okay.

See, a satisfying mystery is about human motivation. As fascinated as we are by the ingenuity of the crime or by the brilliance of its solution, we’re still most curious to know why someone did it — to know how the murder, murderer, and motive are all intertwined. It’s crime gossip, really: how is this murderer like me? How is he or she different?

But in this mystery, we learn that the murderer is a motivation-less monster just trying to survive. It’s a force of nature. And that is as exciting as discovering that a tornado did it.

My grade: C-, because it’s still better than the whole second season.

[Time on bike: 20 minutes.]

What Can I Say About Larry?

In the late 80s, my mother met and married a man I didn’t like much at first.

After living for years with my terrifying but largely responsible father, Larry seemed dreamy and impractical and disconnected from reality — better suited to lazy afternoons watching the Sci-Fi channel or reading fantasy novels than, say, being anything approaching a husband for my mother or a father to me.

But as time went on, I discovered that his gentleness and imagination were just what my mother needed, and thinking back on it now, they were just what all the rest of us needed, too. He gave my mother years of safety and happiness, plenty of those long afternoons reading cool books and talking weird theories about the universe, and he did the same for my sister and I, too, not to mention my nieces.

He introduced me to Middle Earth. It was at his house that I first watched Star Trek: The Next Generation. He typed up my first serious story so I could submit it to magazines…when I was fourteen.

He bore the brunt of my sullen teenage years, too, all the eye-rolling and fun-making of a person who seemed a total crackpot at the time. Larry had deeply felt spiritual beliefs that certainly weren’t like everyone else’s, and I didn’t have much respect at the time for a former hippie still keeping the faith twenty and thirty years later.

I do now, though. I admire Larry’s steadfast lifelong battle against everything practical, everything expected, everything dull and emotionless. He won that battle last night.

Larry died around 7:30 with all of us around him. He seemed content, pleased to see us, and he was more than ready to go after months of having one organ after another replaced by uncomfortable machines. It was strangely appropriate, I guess, that a man almost solely of the spirit would slowly lose his body like that.

He didn’t really need it.

I don’t pray much, but when I do, I usually say, “Please let good happen. Let us recognize it when it does and endure when it doesn’t. Let us be its agents.” Larry was definitely one of its agents, and we’ll all miss him.

He helped provide space and safety for my imagination, and I’ll always be grateful. Toward the end, he couldn’t speak while on the ventilator but he could mouth words. I think he might have said he was proud of me, though it could just be my ego misinterpreting him. Either way, I’ll do everything I can to live up to that.

ExerTrek: Ship in a Bottle

[One man. One exercise bike. One surgery. 138/178 episodes of Star Trek: The Next Generation.]

“Captain, do you remember last week when you were being horribly tortured?”

“Hmmm…tortured. Tortured. Can’t say that I do. I feel fine.”

“Oh. Well, never mind. Let’s have a cheery episode about Sherlock Holmes!”

After spending a few days in Cardassian hands, you’d think Captain Picard would be a little touchy about being trapped anywhere, even the Holodeck with Professor Moriarty.

That said, I still love this episode. Simulations within simulations, theories about the nature of reality, tricks and ruses, a lifetime of faux adventurous reality for Moriarty and the Countess Regina Bartholomew…these are things I always enjoy in Star Trek. I mean, you can have a torture episode in almost any series (maybe not Sesame Street); Star Trek‘s for playing with your mind.

Both Daniel Davis as Moriarty and Stephane Beacham as the Countess really class up the episode; apparently with David Warner’s appearance in the last show, this was a week for putting British actors to work. And of course, Dwight Schultz as Barclay is always fun to watch.

My grade: A. I mean, this is what I show up to see.

[Time on bike: 20 minutes.]

ExerTrek: Chain of Command, Part II

[One man. One exercise bike. One surgery. 137/178 episodes of Star Trek: The Next Generation.]

This episode is about as good as it gets: the interaction between Patrick Stewart and David Warner, their characters sparring intellectually and emotionally with the highest possible stakes of personal identity, makes this one a classic. It’s harrowing to watch in places, especially after dozens of episodes with Picard functioning so highly…all to see him almost broken by torture.

Of course, no one ever mentions this torture again and Picard cheerfully resumes his mission next week with nary an emotional scar. We see no counseling, no PTSD, no slow recovery. He doesn’t squint under bright lights, sit quietly in a corner of Ten Forward nursing a drink, or stick up for tortured people with any greater alacrity or moral outrage. With “The Best of Both Worlds,” we at least got “Family” to show us how Picard recovered from his Borg kidnapping. Here, we get no follow-up.

I think it’s a little disingenuous to do a big dramatic episode on the horrors of torture without showing what happens AFTER torture, without showing that it goes on in the mind long afterward. It’s one thing to “raise awareness” and another thing entirely to really face something and discuss it.

But then, this is Star Trek, and I’m grateful to the writing team for ramping up the emotional involvement of the characters in these last few seasons at all. These are episodes that matter to their characters, regardless of their science fictional content, and that’s the key to good storytelling.

Of course, consequences are important, too…

My grade: A-, judging on this episode’s merits and not the lack of follow-through.

[Time on bike: 20 minutes.]

ExerTrek: Chain of Command, Part I

[One man. One exercise bike. One surgery. 136/178 episodes of Star Trek: The Next Generation.]

In this story, Picard is relieved of command of the Enterprise and sent on a secret mission into Cardassian space with Worf and Crusher to destroy some scary weapon which — of course — only Picard really knows much about. When it turns out to be a trap, everyone but us is surprised. Meanwhile, aboard the Enterprise, a new hard-ass captain changes up the routines of the crew with a seemingly arbitrary dick-headedness.

Yawn.

And I do mean “yawn.” Like many two-part episodes in Star Trek, this first part is poorly paced — doing nothing but establishing the exciting second part. We’re treated to a good five minutes of Picard, Worf, and Crusher talking about spelunking, and at least two extraneous scenes of Captain Jellico being an idiot.

The second part of this episode, coming tomorrow, is what people remember when they think of this as a classic.

On the plus side, this first part shows some interesting sneaking around and special ops work (though that’s something we never really see or hear about again).

My grade: B-

[Time on bike: 15 minutes.]